13 Comments
User's avatar
Karol Joseph's avatar

This essay is an all timer. Before I was even done with the second paragraph I knew this had to be added to my list of essays I want to print out and put in a binder. Nearly every line felt like a moment of reflection. This truly felt like what so many substack posts try to achieve but very few rarely do: an intimate personal essay that leaves the reader struck by the prose and insight alike. Beautiful beautiful beautiful. I mean "Once a full person, now a symbol I have trained my brain to decode." The insight Imbued in this 14 word sentence is absolutely remarkable. I really think it's the comma placement that makes this sentence such a feast. My tendency to want to disentangle the aesthetic value from the message of the words is fruitless in this case(as may be the case for all cases, I mean the whole point of an essay is that if it could've been said effectively in less words it would've been. I'm also realizing that's also its trap since it's assumed that essays are made up of the same type of speech as everyday speech.) Anyways the insight is made buoyant since it can be carried effectively in so few words. We all intuitively know memory but nothing knows it quite like this essay.

naz's avatar

This is stunning — intimate, cerebral, and quietly devastating in the way only honest reflection can be.

Libby Marchant's avatar

I'm not usually a commenter but two nights ago I dreamed about my ex for the first time in over a year. I don't want to get back together - I am very happily in a relationship. In the dream we just walked through my old neighbourhood and he told me he was happy and that life was good to him. Then we hugged each other goodbye and I woke up. Yes, I wish I could text him to say 'I'm really happy you're all good' but I have to believe he was trying to let me know that I don't need to worry about him anymore. Anyway, I am profoundly freaked out by the timing of this piece and also I really loved it. Thanks!

Madeline Tietema's avatar

wow this actually brought me so much peace thank you

naz's avatar

left me thinking about how love doesn’t disappear, it changes form, and how haunting it is that one day we’ll exist in others the same way, not whole, but undeniable.

sabaa's avatar

keep rereading this one over and over again along w the album , this is better song right ? it hurts in the same way

sara b.'s avatar

i really really enjoyed this thank you

grace cameron's avatar

wow. chilling, life imitating art 4 real. thank you for passing on Mendieta's story packaged so eloquently and softly with the fabric of your own

Grace Keane O'Connor's avatar

this read so richly, wonderful essay.

Gary Trujillo's avatar

Wonderful essay. ✨

megan marks's avatar

beautiful 🤍 this resonates with this time of my life so much!!!

Hannah Taub's avatar

Xochitl Gonzalez's 2024 novel, "Anita de Monte Laughs Last" is based on Mendieta's story!

eliza mclamb's avatar

I was actually just speaking to someone about Gonzalez' wok! Adding this to my TBR